It’s pretty late in the day, but maybe you can still nail one of your buddies with these fake items.
Watch and be amused as your friends pick up a Ray Gun and wonder where it went! Or why their Maxim Tomato only healed 4%! There’s even a fake Sticker in here.
Some of them are unchanged. I thought this would improve the confusion, as the victims will see ordinary food items as well as the faux food.